There’s a fence outside of Roger That Community
Garden on 98 Rogers Avenue at Park Place in
Crown Heights, Brooklyn, that declares: Save New York, Save the Garden. The sign says
it all.
“We gotta save the soul of New
York,” noted my friend JC, as we rode visiting gardens under threat Saturday.
This is a city connected between
people and ideas, streets and green spaces, bike lanes and sidewalks, spaces
for cars, and pedestrians, as well as those who yearn for public spaces, where
they can actually put their hands in the dirt – everyone sharing a delicate
community ecology, worth preserving and honoring. Earlier
in the day, a truck had crashed into a wall where we were making a memorial for
people killed by automobiles in New York in 2014, with life imitating art,
demonstrating what happens when we fail to look out for each other. When we lose a green space, this balance is
threatened in a similar way. We lose our sense of community or self. The
private invades the public. Everything
is interconnected in this naked city.
That was the sign I looked at for a
climate change workshop outside the Brooklyn Commons, after a morning painting the
vast memorial for pedestrians lost to traffic violence. All winter long, we have pointed out that green
housing is not built on green gardens, that community gardens help offer a
solution to a city facing the threats of flooding, climate extremes,
congestion, and rippling threats to the sustainability of the city.
Right of Way Street Memorial for Cyclists Killed in 2014. |
Saturday, we would ride bikes to
visit gardens under threat all over New York City. Partnering with 596 Acres, we planned to
ride from Prospect Park to Prospect-Lefferts, Crown Heights and Bushwick, out to the Lower East Side of
Manhattan and Soho, visiting gardens under threat.
The invite for the ride declared:
Join Public Space
Party and 596 Acres to ride to small gardens and community parks that add
essential depth to New York City’s open space network and are in danger of
losing their land to private development: Maple Street, Roger That, Eldert
Street, Children's
Magical, Siempre Verde, and Elizabeth Street. These gardens need community
support in asking the city to move their land from the private market into the
public inventory where they belong. They are small, community spaces that serve
as multi-purpose community living rooms year round.
Amazing Endangered Garden Bike Route created by 596 Acres. |
We met at Grand Army Plaza,
cyclists from New York Bike Dance, as well as Public Space Party, and 596 Acres. The ride would be a time to thank the
gardeners for all they’ve done to create something better of this city and its
fabric of 500 neighborhoods.
The sun shining on the first warm
of Spring, it seemed the whole city was out on the streets.
Our first stop was Maple Street
Garden. Kids were playing in a
tree. It felt as though the whole
neighborhood was on hand.
Maple Street garden
was formed in 2012 by the Maple 3 Block Association and community members who
transformed a trash-strewn vacant lot into a multipurpose garden and community
space. The lot had been vacant and collecting trash for over a decade since its
most recent resident and owner passed away and her home burned down.
As Ali Jacobs, 31, an
active member who lives on Sterling Street stated, “Our neighborhood is
beautiful, but very short on public land. Our garden has no gate nor
lock, it is accessible by the entire neighborhood, and is used heavily by
children and adults as a common outdoor space.”
Paula Segal, of 596 Acres who
serves as an attorney for several the gardens under threat from private
developers, noted they see land as worth more than our lives. They want to
scheme to get our gardens. For two years
this was a garden that increased the
property values for the neighborhood. Before that, it was a trash heap. And no one took notice of the space. We want the convince the city to protect
it. We want to keep the sheriff from
coming. This land was never the
city’s. It was family’s.
We want to point out crucial spaces that are going to disappear, unless
we are as creative as they are, we will lose it. If we keep it, it will be
easier to say this is worth keeping.
The Maple Street
Community Garden is being threatened with demolition by Housing Urban
Development LLC, a private development corporation with a history of subprime
lending and irregular title transfers. Gardeners are resisting eviction by
appearing in Housing Court and urging the City to condemn the property and
transfer it to the Parks Department (next court appearance is May 4, 2015 at 10:30am
at 141 Livingston Street, Brooklyn in room 603).
We zipped up and down around the
neighborhood on our way Roger That Garden, everyone enjoying the lovely day and
our ever connecting story of gardens and people, real estate and community
interests, greed and gratitude.
Roget That community garden was our
next stop. Several of us stopped for
photos outside the space.
David Vigil told the story
of the space.
Grown from a crumbling
building, this is a community space in Crown Heights, Brooklyn
that stewards native plants, grows edibles, and maintains community compost.
Roger That garden is currently under threat of development by a real estate
developer who purchased the deed to the land, subject to hundreds of thousands
of dollars in tax debt liens, for $10 from the man who used to own and operate
a hardware store on this lot before abandoning the buildings. The developers
have attempted to illegally evict the garden through a lock-out. It had been an abandoned space, but now
someone wants to make money with it. But we want to preserve it, noted Vigil.
We want to save it, preserve it and have it secured. The paper for the property needs to move to a
land trust of the Parks department.
Roger That can be
saved if the City invokes eminent domain and buys the property to preserve it
as a Parks Department garden. Eminent domain has been used to create New York’s
parks and open spaces dating at least back to 1807. Prospect Park, Central
Park, the Ocean Parkway Greenway and Astor place are just a few of the over 350
condemnations for the creation or preservation of parks and open spaces that
have been recorded in New York’s county courts.
The next stop for the
ride was Eldert Street Garden in Bushwick. To get there, we rode through the lovely
Brooklyn day, from Crown Heights to Bushwick. Elder Street offers vegetable
plots, educational programming for kids and adults, composting, and a welcoming
public space where folks can relax and connect with the natural world. We stood for a photo in front of the majestic
mural inside the garden. Developers
tried to move in on the space the day before our ride.
Kim Anderson welcomed
up and told the story of the space. Let’s
start from the beginning, she explained.
Originally this space was a pile of rubble from a building in the 1970’s. The land was donated to non-profit with the
expectation that it would become a garden.
In 2009, we approached the two owners of the space and told them we’d
like to make a garden here. So we got
started. They said that was always the
intent of the space, to be a garden. This September, we saw folks
in the lot saying it had been sold.
We checked it out and were told nothing had been sold. But it was. We’re still trying to figure out what
happened there. In January, we learned
out it had been sold for $300,000.00.
Yesterday, we were trying to have a work day and workers showed up
saying they were here to start work on a vacant lot. They were confused. If you want us to move you have to go through
due process, or you are trespassing noted Kim. With those words, we had a
standoff, she recalled. Yet, the garden
had community support. We’re hoping to keep the lot. The Attorney General’s office has not been
contacted by the owners who are required to notify them when selling land in a
non profit. There are restrictions on
dispositions for non profits, noted one of the lawyers, Yet, there is no
information on the deed for the garden.
It was an illegal sale.
As for now, the recent
transfer of the garden to a private for-profit corporation is under
investigation by the New York State Office of the Attorney General. The
gardeners are asserting their rights as tenants under New York City law and
continuing to grow in the face of bullying by the developer. They are asking
that the City halt all construction permits to the property and acquire it for
transfer to the Parks Department.
Anderson explained
what the fight was about, “For those of us without a private garden to grow in,
or a forest to walk in, community gardens are all we have. When we work in our
community gardens, we take back our fundamental right to work
the land, and call a piece of earth our own, no matter how small. And we do it
together.”
From Bushwick riders we
rode over to the Williamsberg Bridge and into Manhattan to visit Siempre
Verde garden, 2 small parcels of public land on Attorney and Stanton
Streets that were reinvigorated by neighbors in 2012 who responded to signs
posted by 596 Acres. Yenta Laureate, Anne Less and other gardeners welcomed
everyone into the garden and told the story of the struggle to save the space
for community use. The garden parcels
are divided by an 18-foot parcel owned by a private developer who has put
forward a proposal to purchase the City-owned properties and use all three as
primarily luxury housing. The gardeners are asking that the City transfer the
existing garden lots to the Parks Department for preservation and acquire the
private parcel to make the garden whole.
"We are essentially
animals so having access to nature provides creature comforts, soothes the
savage soul and regenerates the weary spirit,” says Ann Lee, of Siempre Verde
Community Garden. “Gardens are a place to pause and respite from the grind of
concrete cities. Gardens are the future for urban people."
The fifth stop on the
ride was scheduled to be Children’s
Magical garden, founded in
1982 by community activists with the mission to create a safe space for the
neighborhood’s children to play in and learn about nature. They have been
tirelessly serving their community for 30 years, and have been fighting
development since May 2013, when a portion of their garden was destroyed by a
developer who claims to own the land despite doing nothing with the property
for decades.
Finally, riders visited Elizabeth
Street Garden,
located on city-owned land on Little Italy’s Elizabeth Street. The Garden, open
to the public by local volunteers, provides a sanctuary for residents in an
otherwise dense and tightly packed neighborhood. The site has a long history as
a public school, gathering place, and playground, before it was transformed
into a garden by Elizabeth Street Gallery in 1991. In June 2013, neighbors
started a campaign to permanently preserve the Garden as a New York City
park but the City has not yet transferred the land or indicated that
preservation is a priority. The garden continues to operate with a revocable
lease and has been suggested by elected officials as a site for private housing
development.
“As cities become more
dense and our economy shifts toward sharing, gardens serve as 21st century
community centers where neighbors get to know each other the old-fashioned way
while enjoying shared backyards,” says Friends of Elizabeth Street Garden
President Jeannine Kiely. “Neighborhood green spaces have great value and make
cities livable.”
Lined with statues and
daffodils, the space feels like an Italian sculpture garden. I have ridden by
it for years, but never stepped inside. Supporters
hope the garden can remain open for all, providing a green space in SOHO/
Little Italy, where very little of the space is unpaved.
We hung out talking
and enjoy beauty of the space and what it meant to all of us to have some green
space, where neighbors can meet without an entrance fee.
Paula gave a summary
of where we have been and we talked about ways to keep on supporting these precious
spaces.
“The City needs
to take a more active interest in the fates of these properties and
affirmatively act to preserve the institutions that New Yorkers love,” she
concluded. “This isn't about housing versus gardens. This is about living in a
City that places the needs of people who live in neighborhoods above the potential
for others to make money off those neighborhoods.”
The social rate of
return for community gardens takes place in countless forms. We call for the
city to support
open space, recognizing the multiple benefits of green space in world facing
increasing temperatures and climate chaos.
Thanks to 596 Acres,
the other riders, and the gardeners for
all you do. You are creating a
sustainable future for our city.
Hopefully, we can support you and the delicate ecology you help
preserve. Afterall, when we save the garden, we save NYC.
Save the garden, save NYC and other photos by Erik McGregor |
Trees are the main part of human beings life. Because they provide us oxygen without any cost. We have to save trees or garden. Your are doing great work, thanks for sharing this with us.
ReplyDeletewho to call when you get a flat in Neffsville